The free tip calculator
CalculatorAutomatic gratuity calculator
Gratuity included on the bill? See what the charge comes to and whether anything more is needed to reach the amount you had in mind.
Checked on November 19, 2026
On this page
What an automatic gratuity is
It is a charge the business adds itself, such as 18% for parties of six or more. That example comes from official IRS and Treasury material, and no federal rule we found sets a party size or a rate. Capital One says restaurants often add 18% for large groups and suggests asking what the fee covers (Capital One).
How to avoid tipping twice
Look for the words gratuity, service charge, service fee or auto grat near the bottom of the check. Many checks still print a blank tip line under them, so it is easy to add a second tip without meaning to.
Example: on a $200.00 bill with 18% added, the charge is $36.00. To reach 20% overall you would add $4.00, not another 20%.
Who receives it, and how it is taxed
For federal tax and wage purposes it is generally not a tip. The IRS lists large party, bottle service and room service charges among service charges, and treats them as non-tip wages when paid to staff (IRS Topic 761). Its test for a tip looks for a payment free from compulsion, an amount the customer can set, no employer policy dictating it, and a customer who generally decides who receives it (IRS Revenue Ruling 2012-18). For the difference in words, see gratuity vs tip.
A required charge generally is not a qualified tip for the federal deduction, unless the customer is expressly allowed to change it, including to zero (Treasury final regulation, T.D. 10044).
Do you have to pay it?
Whether a customer can refuse an automatic gratuity depends on state law and on what was disclosed, so there is no single national answer. If a charge surprises you, ask about it before you pay.
State examples
These are examples, not a full list. Rules on service charges differ widely.
- New York: a charge presented as a gratuity must go in full to the staff who gave the service, and an added charge is presumed to be a gratuity unless the employer shows otherwise (New York wage order). A mandatory gratuity escapes sales tax only if it is separately stated, identified as a gratuity and paid entirely to employees (New York Tax Bulletin ST-320).
- California: mandatory tips, gratuities and service charges count as taxable receipts (California CDTFA), and a mandatory service charge may count as a gratuity depending on the facts (California Labor Commissioner).
- Texas: a mandatory gratuity of 20% or less is not taxed if it is clearly labeled and paid to the staff who regularly give the service (Texas Comptroller).
- Hawaii: a hotel or restaurant service charge on food or beverages, or a hotel porterage charge, must go to employees as tip income unless the customer is clearly told it pays other costs (Hawaii statute 481B-14).
Common questions
Do I tip on top of a service charge?
Ally says no additional tip is required when one is included. A charge called a service fee may not all go to staff, so ask if that matters to you.
What does "gratuity included" mean?
The restaurant says a gratuity is already in the bill. Check the amount, then decide whether to add anything.
Is automatic gratuity legal?
Federal guidance treats it as a service charge rather than banning it. Disclosure and refund questions depend on the state.
Sources
- Capital One, When-to-tip guide (October 1, 2026) checked November 19, 2026
- IRS Topic No. 761, Tips: Withholding and reporting (reviewed November 9, 2026) checked November 19, 2026
- IRS Revenue Ruling 2012-18 checked November 19, 2026
- T.D. 10044, Occupations That Customarily and Regularly Received Tips; Definition of Qualified Tips, 91 FR (April 13, 2026), 26 CFR 1.224-1 checked November 19, 2026
- New York Hospitality Industry Wage Order, 12 NYCRR Part 146 (effective December 31, 2016 text) checked November 19, 2026
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, Tax Bulletin ST-320, Gratuities and Service Charges (February 23, 2012) checked November 19, 2026
- California CDTFA, Publication 115, Tips, Gratuities, and Service Charges: Mandatory Charges (September 2018) checked November 19, 2026
- California Labor Commissioner, Tips and Gratuities FAQ checked November 19, 2026
- Texas Comptroller, Publication 94-117, Restaurants and the Texas Sales Tax (03/2014) checked November 19, 2026
- Hawaii Revised Statutes section 481B-14 checked November 19, 2026